In politics, there is perhaps no accusation more damaging than being a “flip-flopper.” It’s a label that suggests a lack of conviction, a hollow core, and a willingness to say anything to get elected. But why is it so uniquely potent? The answer lies not just in politics, but in the fundamental wiring of the human brain.
The destructive power of inconsistency is explained by the psychological theory of cognitive dissonance, pioneered by social psychologist Leon Festinger. The theory states that people experience immense mental discomfort when they hold two or more contradictory beliefs, or when their beliefs are contradicted by new information. To resolve this discomfort, they will instinctively seek to change one of the conflicting elements.
When applied to a political campaign, this principle is a ticking time bomb. Every message you send is a promise of who you are. When a new message contradicts an old one, you force your audience—especially your supporters—into a state of cognitive dissonance. To relieve their mental stress, they are left with two choices: either dismiss the new, contradictory information, or—far more dangerously—change their belief about you.
Consistency as a Strategic Imperative
The primary goal of a communications campaign is to build a simple, coherent, and favorable mental model of your candidate or cause in the mind of the audience. Each consistent message reinforces and strengthens this model. Each inconsistency shatters it, forcing the voter to do the difficult mental work of re-evaluating everything.
Think of your core message as a load-bearing wall. A consistent campaign continually fortifies that wall, making it unshakable. An inconsistent campaign sends out messages like wrecking balls, weakening its own foundation and making it vulnerable to collapse.
This is why negative attack ads that highlight a candidate’s past contradictory statements are so effective. They aren’t just presenting negative information; they are actively triggering cognitive dissonance in the minds of the target’s supporters, introducing a virus of doubt into their mental model.
The Architect of Consistency: A Practical Framework
Message discipline is an active, not a passive, process. It requires a rigorous architectural framework that is understood and executed by every member of the team.
- Define the Core Message Pillars: Before the campaign begins, you must define the three unshakeable pillars of your identity. (e.g., Economic Stability, Community Safety, Modern Infrastructure). These are the foundational values from which all other positions are derived. They are the “why” behind every “what.”
- Utilize the Message Box: A classic but essential tool. This exercise forces you to anticipate attacks and proactively build a consistent narrative. For any given issue, define in a single sentence:
- What we say about ourselves.
- What we say about our opponent.
- What they will say about us.
- What they will say about themselves.
- Master the Rebuttal Bridge: Train every spokesperson to never get trapped by a hostile question. The goal is to acknowledge the question and then “bridge” back to a core message pillar. Phrases like, “That speaks to a larger point…” or “The real issue that people care about is…” are essential tools for steering every conversation back to your consistent, pre-defined territory.
The Fine Line: Consistency vs. Rigidity
Of course, the world is not static. New information emerges, and circumstances change. Does consistency mean you can never evolve your position?
No. But it means that any evolution must be framed carefully, not as a reversal, but as an application of your core values to new facts. The messaging should explain why your unchanging core principle (e.g., “fiscal responsibility”) leads you to a different tactical conclusion now than it did a year ago. The underlying value remains consistent, even if the policy prescription adapts. This is the difference between principled evolution and political expediency.
In a world of information chaos, consistency is a beacon. It is the single most important asset for building the deep, resilient trust required to win.
Aedric's Blog 